Pamela Smart Admits Role in 1990 Murder of Husband
For the first time, Pamela Smart, who is serving a life sentence for conspiring with a teenage student to kill her husband Gregory Smart in 1990, has accepted responsibility for his death. Pamela Smart's case was one of America's first high-profile trials involving a sexual affair between a school staff member and a student, sparking widespread media coverage and inspiring multiple adaptations, including the 1995 film "To Die For" (CNN, NBC, USA Today).
At the time of the murder, Pamela Smart was a 22-year-old high school media coordinator. She began an illicit affair with 15-year-old William Flynn, who ultimately fatally shot her husband. Flynn, along with three other teenagers, cooperated with prosecutors, received shorter sentences, and have since been released (CNN, NBC, USA Today).
Presently, Smart is serving her sentence without the possibility of parole at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in New York. During her incarceration, she has earned two master’s degrees, tutored fellow inmates, been ordained as a minister, and actively worked on the inmate liaison committee (CNN).
Pamela Smart has made several attempts to seek a reduction of her sentence. However, her request was rejected by both the Executive Council and the New Hampshire Supreme Court in 2022 (CNN, NBC, USA Today). Despite this, Smart recently requested an "honest conversation" with New Hampshire Governor Chris Sununu and the state’s Executive Council, hoping that her acceptance of responsibility might lead to a reconsideration of her sentence (CNN, NBC, USA Today).
While this admission marks a significant shift, not everyone is convinced of the extent of her acceptance. Gregory Smart's cousin, Val Fryatt, states that Pamela Smart accepted responsibility "without admitting the facts around what made her fully responsible" (CNN, NBC).
Smart's case remains a poignant example of the complex intersection of personal relationships, media sensationalism, and the legal system. As she continues to navigate her imprisonment, her request for clemency and acceptance of responsibility may open new discussions about justice, forgiveness, and the long-standing impact of a single crime.