FBI Identifies Convicted Serial Rapist as Suspect in 30-Year-Old Shenandoah Murders

FBI Identifies Convicted Serial Rapist as Suspect in 30-Year-Old Shenandoah Murders

3 minute read
Published: 6/21/2024

Nearly 30 years after the brutal murders of two women in Shenandoah National Park, DNA evidence has identified convicted rapist Walter 'Leo' Jackson Sr. as the killer, bringing closure to a decades-old case.

The 1996 murders of Laura 'Lollie' Winans and Julianne 'Julie' Williams in Shenandoah National Park have haunted their families and investigators for decades. Recent advancements in DNA testing and a reinvigorated FBI investigation led to a breakthrough, identifying Walter 'Leo' Jackson Sr., a convicted serial rapist who died in prison in 2018, as the perpetrator. This resolution not only brings a sense of closure to the victims' families but also highlights the power of modern forensic science in solving cold cases.

On May 24, 1996, Laura 'Lollie' Winans, 26, and Julianne 'Julie' Williams, 24, were found murdered at a remote campsite near the Skyland Resort in Shenandoah National Park. The discovery came after family members reported the women missing when they did not return home as scheduled. The National Park Service initiated an extensive search that led to the grim uncovering of their bodies about a week later.

For decades, the case remained unsolved, casting a long shadow over their families and the investigative community. However, a renewed effort by a freshly assigned FBI team in 2021 began to sift through the old evidence with new perspectives and advanced technology. This new approach led to a significant breakthrough, making use of DNA testing capabilities that weren't available during the initial investigation.

Among the crucial pieces of evidence, items recovered from the crime scene were retested by a private laboratory that was able to successfully extract a viable DNA profile. This DNA profile was then submitted to the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), which resulted in a conclusive match with Walter 'Leo' Jackson Sr., a convicted serial rapist from Cleveland, Ohio.

Jackson, who had a disturbing criminal history that included kidnapping, rapes, and assaults, was an experienced residential painter and an avid hiker who frequented Shenandoah National Park. He was serving time in prison when he passed away in March 2018 in Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The successful match was a testament to the meticulous work of the FBI team and the capabilities of forensic science.

One of the critical aspects of the case was a previous wrongful indictment. In 2002, another man, Darryl David Rice, was indicted for the murders of Winans and Williams. However, Rice was later exonerated due to a lack of forensic evidence linking him to the crimes. This unfortunate misstep delayed justice but also underscored the need for solid forensic evidence, which ultimately played a crucial role in solving the case.

Forensic analysis demonstrated an extremely high likelihood that the DNA recovered from the crime scene belonged to Jackson, with experts estimating a one out of 2.6 trillion chance that it was someone else. This strong probability provided the conclusive link necessary to identify Jackson as the killer beyond any reasonable doubt.

The announcement of the case's resolution, though a relief in terms of bringing clarity and closure, was subdued by the absence of the victims' families at the news conference. Understandably, the procession of nearly three decades weighed heavily on them, though they were kept informed of the developments as they unfolded.

Remarkably, the investigation concluded that the motive behind Jackson's brutal act was not connected to the victims' sexual orientation. This finding was important to dispel earlier assumptions and focused solely on Jackson’s history of violent offenses, with no specific targeting of the LGBTQIA+ community.

In the larger context, the identification of Jackson as the murderer marks a significant breakthrough in a case that has spanned nearly three decades. The resolution reinforces the importance of forensic technology in providing answers to long-standing questions and confirming the identity of the perpetrator, even after many years.

By shedding light on the identities and stories of victims like Lollie Winans and Julie Williams, and advancing their cases, forensic science continues to play a pivotal role in law enforcement’s pursuit of truth. The killer’s identification signifies a substantial achievement in the realms of both justice and science, offering a sobering reminder of the relentless work behind solving cold cases.