Hartenstein Ditches Knicks for Thunder and $87M: Bye-Bye, Big Apple!

Hartenstein Ditches Knicks for Thunder and $87M: Bye-Bye, Big Apple!

3 minute read
Published: 7/2/2024

In a stunning move, Isaiah Hartenstein snubbed the Knicks' $72.5 million offer, opting for a three-year, $87 million deal with the Oklahoma City Thunder, leaving New York scrambling for a new center.

Faced with a loaded bank account and the allure of Oklahoma's scenic flatlands, Isaiah Hartenstein shunned New York's best bid, leaving the Knicks fretting over their luxury tax woes and scouting backups. With Hartenstein's departure, the Knicks are contemplating everything from Jericho Sims to naming the arena after Mitchell Robinson's physical therapist to ensure their center position isn't a revolving door of injuries.

The Thunder made their intentions clear from the get-go, offering Hartenstein a front-loaded deal that surpasses $30 million in the first year alone. Knicks fans, therefore, might find some solace in blaming the Thunder’s financial acrobatics rather than the Knicks’ commitment. New York’s four-year, $72.5 million offer was ultimately outmatched by Oklahoma City's three-year, $87 million package.

Isaiah Hartenstein’s departure undoubtedly leaves a gaping void at the center position for the Knicks. The German-American player had become a beloved fixture in New York, significantly boosting his stats over the past season. With averages of 7.8 points, 8.3 rebounds, 2.5 assists, 1.2 steals, and 1.1 blocks per game, Hartenstein was nothing short of a Swiss Army knife on the court.

Nevertheless, the Knicks couldn’t match the Thunder’s financial might, mainly due to their luxury tax situation and limited cap space. Enter Mitchell Robinson, the Knicks’ remaining mainstay at center, hobbling off the pages of the injury report. Team doctors probably have his MRI scans framed like artwork in their offices.

A bigger laugh—or cry—comes from the fact that the Thunder executives traveled all the way to Eugene, Oregon, to meet Hartenstein, a level of dedication usually reserved for political campaigns and desperate marriage proposals. Their enthusiastic pitch apparently did the trick.

One might think Hartenstein was more than eager to swap Broadway for a life of thrilling tornado warnings, judging by his Instagram message. He posted a heartfelt thank-you to New York City and his teammates, saying how much he cherished his tenure with the Knicks. Meanwhile, OKC was already rolling out the red carpet—or perhaps a nice blue one to match their team colors.

Rumors are swirling about who the Knicks will tap to fill Hartenstein’s size-16 sneakers. The list of possibilities includes Jericho Sims, Mo Bamba, Goga Bitzade, and Nick Richards—all names that could either make or break the Knicks' upcoming season. Perhaps they’ll just flip a coin—or better yet, consult a Magic 8-ball.

Hartenstein’s new contract is intriguing beyond just the eye-watering sum. The third year isn’t even guaranteed, showing that the Thunder has a backup parachute in case the serene Oklahoman lifestyle doesn’t work its magic on him. Even then, this contract is a quantum leap from Hartenstein’s career earnings of approximately $22.65 million prior to this deal.

While hopeful for a new era under Hartenstein’s center presence, Thunder fans are likely aware that high expectations often lead to spectacular collapses. But hey, we’re not here to jinx anything. Perhaps Hartenstein will be the hero the Thunder needs, ushering in more wins and fewer press conferences featuring coach Mark Daigneault sighing deeply.

Back in New York, the Knicks have their own pondering to do. With luxury tax constraints strangling their wallet, focusing on developing Mitchell Robinson, barring another inconveniently-timed sprain, might be their best bet. Or they might throw some spare change at another hopeful—anything to appease a fanbase that’s seen more tears than triumphs as of late.

As the dust settles, it’ll be interesting to see how both teams fare. Will Isaiah Hartenstein become the Thunder’s superhero or just another expensive lesson in their financial history? And will the Knicks find their next center without having to hold bake sales to fund the deal? One thing's for sure: both teams have set the stage for an eventful season, and whether fans will be laughing or crying come playoff time remains to be seen.