Involuntary Manslaughter Charges Against Alec Baldwin Dismissed in 'Rust' Shooting Case

Involuntary Manslaughter Charges Against Alec Baldwin Dismissed in 'Rust' Shooting Case

3 minute read
Published: 7/15/2024

Alec Baldwin's involuntary manslaughter charges in the 2021 'Rust' shooting have been dismissed with prejudice due to prosecutors' willful withholding of critical evidence, according to Judge Mary Marlowe Sommer.

The dismissal stems from prosecutors’ failure to provide the defense with crucial evidence in a timely manner, with accusations pointing to their concealment of information potentially implicating an external source for the live ammunition. As a result of this discovery violation, Baldwin's charges cannot be refiled. The ruling closely follows the conviction of on-set armorer Hannah Gutierrez-Reed for related charges, while civil litigation from the Hutchins family against Baldwin is set to continue.

The incident in question occurred on the set of the movie 'Rust' during a rehearsal in 2021, where a prop gun held by Alec Baldwin went off, resulting in the tragic death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. The accidental discharge also injured director Joel Souza, causing outrage and leading to a detailed investigation into the circumstances of the shooting.

Central to the dismissal of the charges was the argument posed by Baldwin’s defense team that prosecutors had concealed critical evidence. The evidence in question pertained to live rounds supplied by Seth Kenney, which prosecutors allegedly hid from the defense. This omission became a decisive factor in the court's decision.

Judge Mary Marlowe Sommer, presiding over the case, ruled that the state’s discovery violation was both intentional and deliberate, justifying the dismissal with prejudice. This legal term indicates that the charges against Baldwin cannot be refiled, providing a firm closure to his criminal liability in the incident.

The ruling also came against the backdrop of significant developments involving others on the set of 'Rust.' Notably, on-set armorer Hannah Gutierrez-Reed had already been found guilty of involuntary manslaughter related to the same incident. She was sentenced to 18 months in prison earlier in March for her role in failing to ensure the safety of the prop firearms used during filming.

The family of Halyna Hutchins, represented by attorney Gloria Allred, has expressed their intention to pursue civil litigation against Alec Baldwin. Despite the dismissal of criminal charges, the family aims to seek accountability and justice through the civil courts. Matthew Hutchins, Halyna's widower, has voiced his respect for the court's decision but remains adamant about holding Baldwin accountable.

The decision led to significant reactions from various parties. Alec Baldwin expressed his heartfelt gratitude to his supporters through social media, acknowledging the difficult journey he has faced since the tragic incident. Following the dismissal, Baldwin was seen in court sobbing and embracing his wife, Hilaria Baldwin, a moment that underscored the emotional toll of the proceedings.

Complicating the case further, special prosecutor Erlinda Johnson resigned shortly before the hearing on the motion to dismiss. This resignation added another layer of complexity to the legal proceedings, raising questions about the coordination and handling of the case by the prosecution.

As the criminal charges come to a close, attention now shifts to the forthcoming civil lawsuit. The outcome of this lawsuit remains pending, with potential implications for Baldwin's career and financial standing. The legal battles underscore the ongoing fallout and the broader dialogue on safety protocols and responsibility in the film industry.