Senate Passes Landmark Bill to Enhance Online Safety for Children

Senate Passes Landmark Bill to Enhance Online Safety for Children

4 minute read
Published: 7/30/2024

In a decisive 91-3 vote, the Senate passed landmark legislation to safeguard children from online harms, mandating social media platforms like Facebook and TikTok to implement stringent protections for young users.

The legislation, comprising the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) and the Children and Teens’ Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA 2.0), demands social media giants implement measures to prevent harmful content and protect minors' data. With significant bipartisan backing, the bills target issues like online bullying, data privacy, and addictive features, aiming to reshape online safety for children and teens. However, its future in the House remains uncertain due to potential First Amendment conflicts and the legislative body's current summer recess.

KOSA mandates that social media platforms exercise what it terms a 'duty of care' for their younger users. This duty involves not only the prevention of online harm such as bullying, violence, and sexual exploitation but also includes safeguarding the personal information of minors. Platforms would also be required to disable addictive features and tailor algorithms specifically for children’s accounts to ensure they are not exposed to harmful content.

Further enhancing digital security, COPPA 2.0 introduces stringent modifications to child privacy laws. The updated act raises the age threshold for collecting personal information from users from under 13 to under 17. This expansion means broader protection, prohibiting targeted advertising toward teens and granting minors the right to have their personal information deleted. These measures aim to shield teenagers from invasive data practices that could have long-term implications on their privacy.

The overwhelming Senate support illustrates the urgency and bipartisan agreement on the necessity for stronger online safety measures for children. However, the legislative journey is far from over as the bill now heads to the House of Representatives, which is currently on summer recess until September. House Speaker and other representatives have voiced concerns that some provisions might impinge upon free speech rights guaranteed by the First Amendment.

Parents of children who have tragically died by suicide following online bullying have been among the most vocal advocates for this legislation. Their testimonies have highlighted the harsh realities of unregulated social media environments and the profound impacts that online interactions can have on young people's mental health. These heartbreaking stories catalyzed the emotional Senate hearings and played a crucial role in shaping the urgency and content of KOSA.

Tech giants, including Snap, X, and Microsoft, have thrown their support behind the legislation, recognizing the need for robust protections for younger users. However, a notable exception is Meta, which has not clearly stated its stance on the bill, leading to speculation about its position on these substantial regulatory changes.

The bill includes amendments aimed at addressing a spectrum of concerns, especially those related to access to information on LGBTQ issues and reproductive rights. These adjustments were made in response to critiques about the potential overreach of the acts, ensuring that essential supportive and educational content remains accessible to minors while also affording them greater protections.

One of the contentious aspects of the bill is KOSA's perceived potential to weaken Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. Section 230 is a critical statute that offers online services immunity from liability for third-party content posted on their platforms. Some Senators worry that KOSA's provisions could inadvertently expose platforms to greater legal risks, thereby impacting the broader dynamics of internet operations and content moderation.

Despite these concerns, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Commerce Committee Chair Maria Cantwell have been instrumental in advancing the legislation. They worked closely with the bills' sponsors to address various objections and build a coalition of support. Schumer faced criticism for delays in progressing the bill earlier, but has since successfully navigated its passage through the Senate.

The future of KOSA and COPPA 2.0 now hinges on the House's review and modifications. Advocates are hopeful that the emotional and powerful testimonies from parents and the broad support from tech companies will help push the legislation through. However, it remains to be seen how the debates over free speech and Section 230 will influence the outcome.

As the discussion moves forward, the primary goal remains clear: creating a safer online environment for children and teenagers. By implementing these legislative measures, lawmakers hope to curb the detrimental effects of social media on young users and set a new standard for online safety and privacy.