Florida AG Argues Against Execution of Parkinson's Inmate

Florida AG Argues Against Execution of Parkinson's Inmate

3 minute read
Published: 8/28/2024

Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody insists the scheduled execution of Loran Cole, a death row inmate with Parkinson's, should proceed despite concerns over his condition and a late appeal to the Supreme Court.

The upcoming execution of Loran Cole, convicted for the brutal 1994 murders of two siblings, has reignited debates over the death penalty in Florida, particularly regarding the implications of his Parkinson’s disease on the execution process. With his execution set for Thursday evening and a late appeal by Cole’s legal team citing health concerns, Moody argues that delays are unwarranted, stating Cole had ample time to raise his medical issues prior to the signing of his death warrant.

Loran Cole, who has been on death row for nearly three decades, was convicted for a series of heinous crimes committed in Ocala National Forest, where he kidnapped, raped, and murdered two children. His conviction has remained a point of division in the criminal justice system, particularly as he now faces the end of his legal battle with the imminent execution scheduled for 6 p.m. on Thursday at the Florida State Prison. The execution follows Governor Ron DeSantis' signing of Cole's death warrant in July, initiating the final stages of the judicial process.

According to Moody's office, Cole was aware of his Parkinson's symptoms for seven years yet did not raise this concern until the signing of his death warrant. This timeline has led the Attorney General to argue that the legal attempts to halt Cole's execution are not justifiable and come too late. She emphasized that having knowledge of his medical condition for this length of time diminishes the credibility of his claims for a stay of execution.

Cole's legal representation counters by asserting that his Parkinson's disease is severe enough to impede the humane administration of his death sentence. They argue that involuntary body movements associated with the disease could complicate crucial medical procedures, particularly the placement of intravenous lines necessary for lethal injection. This contention raises significant questions about the methods of execution and whether they can truly meet standards of decency in light of specific medical disabilities.

The debate over the execution has broader implications given that many of Florida's death penalty procedures are not subject to public records laws. This secrecy has fueled public concerns over the potential mishandling or botched executions seen in other states, prompting advocates for reform to call for greater transparency in the execution protocols. Such fears are exacerbated by allegations of abuse that Cole claims he suffered during his time at a state-run reform school, which his attorneys have argued impacts the legitimacy of his sentence.

On August 23, the Florida Supreme Court denied an appeal that would have halted Cole’s execution. This decision came amidst ongoing controversies surrounding both the death penalty and the treatment of inmates with serious medical conditions. Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody argued that the execution of an inmate with Parkinson's symptoms should not be delayed because his appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court came too late. Moody's office stated that Cole knew for at least seven years about his Parkinson’s disease symptoms but delayed raising concerns until his death warrant was signed.

As the scheduled date approaches, calls for further examination of Cole's medical state and the ethical implications of his execution continue to swell from various advocacy groups and legal observers. Opinions vary widely regarding the appropriateness of conducting an execution under these circumstances, with some suggesting that executing an inmate afflicted with a debilitating disease might contradict evolving standards of human rights and humane treatment.

The outcome of Cole's execution will likely impact future discussions surrounding the application of the death penalty, particularly with regard to individuals suffering from serious health issues. As ongoing debates persist both inside and outside the courtroom, attention turns to Thursday's proceedings and the final fate of Loran Cole, a figure at the center of Florida's contentious death penalty discourse.