Orioles Bid Adieu to Kimbrel: Playoff Plans Unraveled?

Orioles Bid Adieu to Kimbrel: Playoff Plans Unraveled?

3 minute read
Published: 9/19/2024

In a shocking twist reminiscent of a late-game meltdown, the Baltimore Orioles designated Craig Kimbrel for assignment after a season that began with save opportunities and ended with unceremonious six-run blowouts.

After starting the season strong with 23 saves and a respectable 2.80 ERA, Kimbrel's second half quickly unraveled, showcasing a jaw-dropping 10.59 ERA and blowing six saves. Now, the team is left to ponder how a supposed ‘saves expert’ could go from lights out to lighting up the scoreboard for their opponents, all while being eclipsed by the ghost of his former self and a replacement closer named Seranthony Domínguez.

Kimbrel, who earlier this season was a beacon of hope for the Orioles' pitching staff, now finds himself looking for a new team after the Orioles decided enough was enough. His performance had become a bit of an enigma, as he tossed on the mantle of a reliable closer in the first half, only to transition into role akin to an uninvited guest who overstays their welcome at an awkward party.

In an effort to make sense of this performance rollercoaster, statistically-minded fans have been combing through Kimbrel's season like they're dissecting a complex crime drama. Initially, the numbers told a reliable story: Kimbrel racked up 23 saves, posting a 2.80 ERA in the first half of the season. However, the narrative began to shift dramatically as he entered the second half, where Kimbrel struggled significantly, posting a 10.59 ERA.

His last appearance, a cataclysmic outing against the San Francisco Giants, saw Kimbrel send six earned runs hurtling across the plate as if on an express train headed directly for disaster. In a classic reversal of roles, the 'closer' ended up providing a whole lot of 'open-bar' for the opposition. Fans have unceremoniously dubbed that outing as 'the day the lights went out in Baltimore.'

The Orioles' front office made their choice clear when they turned to Seranthony Domínguez, a name that perfumed the air with hope while also promising uncertainty. The decision to hand the closer role over to Domínguez can be likened to asking a cat to babysit a litter of puppies; one might succeed, but it’s equally likely chaos will ensue.

For Kimbrel, the season has been akin to a midlife crisis caught on tape, punctuated by lofty expectations crashing down like a meteor. Until then, he had been a nine-time All-Star, with a storied career that boasts a total of 440 saves—enough to place him fifth in the illustrious annals of MLB history. His journey also saw a Rookie of the Year accolade in 2011, proving that, once upon a time, he was not just a name in the box score but a legend in the making.

Now, with his future in the sport hanging by a thread, Kimbrel faces questions that strike deeper than the ERA that so recently spiraled out of control. Will he manage to recalibrate his career, or has he reached the twilight of what was once presumed a golden arm? Only time will tell, but in what is reportedly a spicy free-agent market, there’s bound to be a team willing to take a chance, hoping the Kimbrel of yesteryear could miraculously reemerge.

As for the Orioles, they must reconcile their hopes of playoff contention with Kimbrel's unexpected absence. The decision to cut ties with a player commanding a one-year contract worth $13 million is not just a fiscal maneuver; it reflects the stark reality of the sport where trading in your star closer often feels like pulling the ripcord on your parachute halfway through a jump. It’s risky, it’s chaotic, and it certainly keeps fans at the edge of their seats.