84-Year-Old Arrested for 1974 Wisconsin Hitchhiker Murder

84-Year-Old Arrested for 1974 Wisconsin Hitchhiker Murder

3 minute read
Published: 11/10/2024

An 84-year-old man, Jon Miller, has been arrested for the 1974 murder of hitchhiker Mary K. Schlais in Wisconsin, thanks to a breakthrough in forensic genetic genealogy linking him to the crime scene.

The arrest marks a significant advancement in a cold case that has haunted law enforcement for nearly five decades. Mary K. Schlais, 25, was found murdered in Spring Brook while hitchhiking to an art show in Chicago. Thanks to DNA evidence extracted from a hat left at the scene, authorities connected Miller to the crime, leading to his confession. This development not only provides closure to Schlais's family but also highlights the potential of modern forensic techniques in solving long-standing criminal cases.

Miller was arrested after a DNA investigation revealed a match between his genetic profile and the evidence from the crime scene. The hat discovered at the site of the murder provided the key evidence needed for this breakthrough, allowing investigators to trace his lineage and establish a connection to the victim. Sheriff Kevin Bygd described the case as a lengthy effort spanning over 35 years, emphasizing the challenges law enforcement faced in bringing justice to Schlais and her family.

Prior to Miller's arrest, the investigation into Schlais’ murder had reached a standstill, with no viable suspects identified for decades. Randall Woodfield, a known serial killer, had previously been considered a prime suspect in the case, but no solid evidence ever linked him to the crime. The collaboration between the Dunn County Sheriff’s Office and Ramapo College in New Jersey proved crucial, as their expertise in genetic genealogy provided new investigative avenues to explore.

Upon interrogation, Jon Miller initially denied any involvement in the murder. However, the presentation of the DNA evidence prompted a shift in his stance, and he ultimately confessed to the crime. During the interrogation, he reportedly remained calm and mentioned feeling a sense of relief after admitting his guilt. This emotional response signals the complexity surrounding long-buried incidents from the past and the psychological toll they can take on individuals.

The effects of this arrest not only resonate on a personal level but also reflect broader implications for law enforcement. The Dunn County Sheriff’s Office viewed Miller’s apprehension as a remarkable victory for their agency, demonstrating the effectiveness of advanced forensic methods in resolving cold cases. Sheriff Bygd praised the cooperation between traditional investigative techniques and modern genetic analysis, emphasizing how such partnerships are essential for justice.

Family members of Mary Schlais expressed a mixture of emotions upon learning of the news. While there is relief that progress has been made, the pain of losing a loved one remains palpable even after so many years. The impact of Schlais's murder rippled through the community, highlighting the potential dangers that hitchhikers faced during that era and raising awareness about the safety of individuals traveling alone.

The use of forensic genetic genealogy has become increasingly prevalent in solving cold cases. In recent years, numerous long-unsolved crimes have been re-examined with this technology, which leverages DNA databases to find familial connections. Each success story adds weight to the importance of investing in forensic advancements for law enforcement agencies across the nation.

As the legal proceedings against Miller continue, attention will focus on how this case unfolds in the courtroom. Prosecutors will likely build their case around the DNA evidence collected and the confession made by Miller. This will put to the test not just the strength of the evidence but also the legal process in handling historic cases that arise many years after the crime was committed.

For those who are close to the story, including law enforcement officials, community members, and the family of Mary Schlais, this arrest marks a significant development in a case that has persisted for decades. The arrest was made possible through forensic genetic genealogy that connected Jon Miller to evidence from the crime scene, highlighting the advances in investigative methods available to law enforcement.