Georgia Man Arrested in 1985 Church Murders After Wrongful Conviction Exoneration

Georgia Man Arrested in 1985 Church Murders After Wrongful Conviction Exoneration

3 minute read
Published: 12/13/2024

Erik Kristensen Sparre was arrested in Georgia for the 1985 murders of Harold and Thelma Swain, following DNA evidence from the crime scene that led authorities to identify him as a suspect.

The arrest of Sparre marks a significant development in a case that remained unsolved for nearly 40 years, highlighting the challenges of wrongful convictions as it comes after Dennis Perry was exonerated in 2021, having spent two decades in prison for the crime. Charged with two counts of felony murder and aggravated assault, Sparre was linked to the Swains' deaths through DNA evidence from glasses found at the Rising Daughter Baptist Church, and a recorded confession to his ex-wife further implicates him in the notorious case.

The murders of Harold and Thelma Swain took place on a summer day in 1985 at the Rising Daughter Baptist Church in Waverly, Georgia. The couple was known in the community and their violent deaths sent shockwaves through the small town, prompting an extensive investigation that ultimately yielded no leads for nearly two decades.

Dennis Perry was initially arrested and convicted for the Swains' murders in 2003 based on circumstantial evidence, including testimony from a police informant who was compensated $12,000. However, Perry maintained his innocence throughout his time in prison. His conviction was eventually overturned in 2021 when DNA evidence from the crime scene was tested and proved not to match his profile, leading to his exoneration after 20 years behind bars.

Sparre emerged as a suspect after investigators revisited the case following Perry's exoneration. The breakthrough came with DNA analysis conducted on a pair of glasses discovered at the crime scene, which matched Sparre's DNA. This pivotal evidence prompted law enforcement to take further action, eventually leading to his arrest in Waynesville, Georgia, where he resided.

The Georgia Innocence Project played a crucial role in the renewed investigation into the Swains' murders. Their efforts to ensure that justice was served after Perry's wrongful conviction have been widely acknowledged. The organization advocates for reforms in the criminal justice system to prevent similar miscarriages of justice in the future.

According to reports, Sparre's ex-wife provided key testimony that included a recorded confession in which he allegedly admitted to the murders. This confession, alongside the DNA evidence, heightened the urgency of the investigation and contributed to his arrest. As of now, Sparre has denied involvement in the Swains' deaths, but details regarding his legal representation have not been disclosed.

The long timeline of this case, from the murders of Harold and Thelma Swain to the arrest of Erik Kristensen Sparre, illustrates the complexities that can impede the resolution of homicide cases. After nearly 40 years, the pursuit of justice for the Swains continues to resonate within the community and raise significant questions about the reliability of evidence and witness testimonies in these investigations.

Currently, Sparre faces serious charges including two counts of felony murder and aggravated assault. The legal proceedings are expected to unfold as investigators gather more information.

The wrongful conviction of Dennis Perry has led him to reconnect with family and friends, reflecting on the years lost due to a miscarriage of justice. Perry's exoneration has drawn national attention to issues surrounding wrongful convictions and the importance of reliable forensic evidence in criminal cases.

As the legal process advances for Sparre, both the community and advocates for justice will be closely monitoring developments. The contours of the case will likely continue to evolve.