Sanctuary Cities' New Motto: Local Cops vs. Border Cops

Sanctuary Cities' New Motto: Local Cops vs. Border Cops

3 minute read
Published: 3/30/2025

In a sanctuary city showdown, Rochester officials are fuming as police assist Border Patrol during a routine traffic stop, raising eyebrows about whether the city's immigration policy is just a suggestion.

The clash over local immigration enforcement in Rochester took center stage when police officers provided assistance to Border Patrol during a traffic stop, much to the dismay of city leaders. Mayor Malik Evans claimed this breach undermines the city's long-standing sanctuary resolution, while Police Chief David Smith warned officers not to engage in immigration enforcement, despite the union's defense that they merely responded to an 'emergency' call. The drama raises crucial questions about the balance between local policies and federal requests, making every traffic stop in Rochester feel like a episode of 'Law & Order: Immigration Unit.'

The incident unfolded when Rochester police received a call from Border Patrol requesting assistance with a van allegedly occupied by up to eight individuals. The precise algebra of the situation was reportedly 'A Van with Eight Strangers' equals 'A Call to Action,' leading local police to respond as if they were auditioning for a buddy cop film.

Mayor Malik Evans, ever the enthusiastic protector of the city's sanctuary resolution, expressed outrage at the police's decision. "This action violates both our city's sanctuary resolution and a police general order regarding immigration law enforcement," he declared, presumably shaking his fist at a calendar that reminded him of just how long this policy has been in place. After all, Rochester's sanctuary resolution has been around since 1986 and even got an enthusiastic 'yes' during its 2017 reaffirmation.

While Mayor Evans was issuing strong statements, Police Chief David Smith was equally expressive in his concern about the officers' actions. He emphasized that, despite the spontaneous response to Border Patrol's plea, local police are expected to refrain from involvement in immigration issues. Chief Smith’s stern tone likely aimed to remind everyone that their badge does not also come with a federal stamp of approval.

However, the police union leaped to the defense of the officers, offering a counter-narrative that could easily fit into any courtroom drama. They claimed that the officers didn’t pry into the immigration status of the individuals involved and were merely reacting in a crisis. After all, what could be more emergency-like than a frantic call to assist Border Patrol with a potential van full of suspects? One can only imagine the scenarios that 'emergency' could involve in their playbook.

The situation escalated when, as a part of this 'emergency response,' Rochester police ordered the occupants out of the van and assisted in handcuffing them. According to city policy, this act didn't just stretch the bounds of local law but took a flying leap over them, landing squarely in a prohibited area, the kind that comes with unsolicited paperwork and possible lawsuits. Thankfully, police reports indicated that no violence or force was reported during this situation, much to the relief of everyone hoping to avoid an episode of 'Cops: Sanctuary City Edition.'

In what can only be described as an observation worthy of a sitcom backdrop, Chief Smith noted that the Border Patrol officers on the scene displayed a notable lack of urgency. This part of the incident raises the question: did the local officers overstep due to a misperception of urgency, or were the Border Patrol agents just enjoying a leisurely afternoon?

As the dust settles, Rochester finds itself standing at a crossroads, feeling almost like a reluctant actor in a play that no one auditioned for. Every traffic stop now carries the weight of scrutiny, leaving both locals and officers to wonder how each situation will play out under the glaring eye of the media. The city's sanctuary resolution stands firmly, but with these events, it may need a new tagline. Perhaps, 'Welcome to Rochester: Where Every Van is Potentially Governmental' would suffice, capturing the delicate balance of local policy against federal whims in America’s complex immigration narrative.