Giants Draft Dart: A Bullseye or Just a Throw in the Dark?

Giants Draft Dart: A Bullseye or Just a Throw in the Dark?

4 minute read
Published: 4/25/2025

In a bold move at the 2025 NFL Draft, the New York Giants traded their way back into the first round to select Ole Miss' Jaxson Dart, who promises to lead the team to the Super Bowl—after a few practice sessions, of course.

In a gamble that would make a Las Vegas high roller blush, the Giants sent a boatload of picks to the Texans to snag Dart with the 25th overall selection. Dubbed a dual-threat quarterback, Dart dazzled in college, racking up over 10,600 yards and setting Ole Miss records all while keeping his interception count lower than a rookie’s excuse list. With the Ghosts of Quarterbacks Past—Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston—competing for the starter spot, the Giants are banking on Dart to be their golden ticket to the Super Bowl, or at the very least, a clear route up the NFC East standings.

Dart's college career was nothing short of remarkable, showcasing a resume that would make anyone nod in approval. As a three-year starter at Ole Miss, he not only became the Rebels' all-time leader in wins and passing yards but also managed to complete 66% of his passes, which is statistically speaking, quite good. His tenure at Ole Miss wasn't merely filled with passing touchdowns, but he amassed a whopping 72 touchdowns against just 22 interceptions— a ratio that we can only assume brought a smile to more than a few coaches' faces.

Dart's impressive performance reached new heights in the 2024 season when he led the FBS with an eye-popping 10.8 yards per attempt. To put that in perspective, if yards were dollars, Dart would have been a millionaire by halftime. He averaged 329.2 passing yards per game that year—ranked a solid third in the NCAA—while also displaying his mobility by adding 495 rushing yards and three rushing touchdowns. It seems Dart isn't just about arm strength; he can run when needed, perhaps leaving defenders in a state of perpetual confusion.

Upon hearing his name called at the draft, Dart's reaction was filled with the kind of pure joy typically reserved for children on Christmas morning. He celebrated with family and friends, a wholesome image that contrast sharply with the usual stress-induced spectacles of draft day. Perhaps he was already drafting up plans for the parade route in his hometown; a tad premature, yet who could blame him?

However, the Giants’ decision to trade high picks to grab Dart indicates they genuinely believe he’s the answer to their quarterback woes. Having already signed veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, the Giants are not leaving any stone unturned in their quest for victory. While Dart brings an exciting new chapter, the existence of two seasoned quarterbacks makes for an interesting dynamic in the team's locker room. Will the veterans take Dart under their wing, or will it resemble a scene from ‘Survivor’ with Dart as the unsuspecting rookie? Only time will tell.

Rumors swirled that the Giants might instead pursue Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders, another talented prospect who had caught the scouting department’s eye. In the end, they opted for Dart, who seems intent on paying homage to the organization's towering history—if not by strong performances on the field, then perhaps through sheer charisma. He praised the Giants, calling it a 'historic and legendary organization' and has set the ambitious goal of winning Super Bowls. One can’t help but wonder if he delivered that line with a wide smile or a brisk nod akin to a character in a classic sports drama... thank goodness we promised not to go there.

Standing at 6-foot-2 and weighing 223 pounds, Dart is well-built for the physical demands of the NFL. However, one wonders if this is also an approximate weight for the expectations resting squarely on his shoulders. The pressure is palpable as Giants fans desperately seek a glimmer of hope amidst years of quarterback controversies and head-scratching decisions.

Despite the whirlwind surrounding him, Dart appears unfazed. The expectations are rising, and the stakes are higher than a game-winning field goal attempt in the dying seconds. Yet, in this age of instant gratification, where fans often expect success from draft picks right out of the gate, it will be interesting to monitor Dart’s development amidst a complex quarterback situation. And if all else fails, he can always lean on those historic references.

In conclusion, if Dart's early days as a Giant resemble his college career, we could be in for a treat—or at the very least, a slightly less confusing journey than prior seasons. The Giants have thrown the dart. Now, all they need is for it to land squarely on the bullseye. If nothing else, it will certainly add a layer of intrigue to the upcoming NFL season, and with any luck, a little more excitement in the NFC East race.