Philly Sports Bar Fumbles Into Hate Speech Scandal

Philly Sports Bar Fumbles Into Hate Speech Scandal

4 minute read
Published: 5/5/2025

A Temple University student was suspended after a shocking antisemitic display at a Philadelphia bar, prompting Barstool Sports' Dave Portnoy to launch an investigation and arrange a rather unconventional 'teaching moment' at Auschwitz.

In a turn of events that has sent shockwaves through the campus and beyond, a student at Temple University was suspended following the display of an antisemitic sign at a Philadelphia bar, which has drawn the wrath of Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy. As the bar faces scrutiny from law enforcement and the Anti-Defamation League, this incident has ignited broader conversations about antisemitism and accountability—and left many wondering if a bar tab could truly buy a lesson in empathy.

The incident reportedly unfolded during a bottle service order when a sign reading 'F**k the Jews' was displayed, ostensibly as a misguided attempt at humor. It's safe to say that this particular brand of comedy didn't land quite as intended, sparking outrage instead of laughter. Unfortunately, the laughter at this bar was replaced by a collective gasp, shortly followed by the sound of someone awkwardly trying to refund their drink in hopes of vanishing from the scene.

In response to the disturbing event, Dave Portnoy didn't waste time critiquing the actions of those involved. Not one to shy away from controversy, his immediate reaction was a pledge to take a closer look at the incident. Portnoy stated, "This could be turned into a learning experience," but many are left wondering how exactly one learns compassion through the lens of a poorly executed bottle service. Perhaps the entire bottle of vodka should be interrogated for its role in this debacle.

Barstool Sansom Street acted swiftly, firing the two servers implicated in the incident. Their termination might serve as a lesson in accountability, albeit one enforced with the kind of speed typically reserved for a bar special on a Saturday night. In a world where actions have consequences, those servers are now left with an illuminated path toward alternative employment—hopefully one with a robust diversity training program.

The ramifications of this incident have also reached the higher echelons of Temple University. University President John Fry lamented the matter as 'deeply disturbing,' a sentiment echoed by many who remain in disbelief that such hostility could manifest in a social setting, particularly one meant to be filled with revelry and camaraderie. This is not what they meant by 'spreading good vibes only.'

Adding another layer to this tale, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) has caught wind of the situation and alerting law enforcement to the matter, like an uninvited guest pointing out festival rules—specifically, the one about no hate speech allowed. The ADL's involvement signals not just an interest, but a pressing demand for consequences and dialogue—a conversation that many had hoped would remain dormant.

And just when you thought the situation couldn't become more absurd, Portnoy's plan for those responsible involves a visit to Auschwitz, where they are to engage in what he deems a 'teaching moment.' While well-intentioned, one can't help but contemplate how a barroom misadventure could lead to a lesson in history that absolutely no one anticipated. It's like taking a group of rambunctious students to a history class on field trips but with longer-term goals of turning a bar sign into a report card.

Meanwhile, Temple University is grappling with its own issues stemming from this incident. The Department of Education has reached out about investigations into antisemitic discrimination and harassment on campus, ensuring that the academic institution faces as much scrutiny as its beleaguered bar. It feels almost poetic: while the bottle service ignited a small fire, the university finds itself staring at an inferno of broader implications.

The Philadelphia police have now stepped in, treating this situation with the seriousness it deserves. Perhaps the bar staff thought they were merely serving drinks and managing social diversions, but they inadvertently might have mixed up a cocktail of legal consequences instead. As investigations continue, one thing is certain: the Philadelphia police are investigating the antisemitic incident at the Barstool bar.

For those at Temple University and within the Philadelphia community, discussions surrounding antisemitism have once again surfaced. This time, the topic comes complete with the uncomfortable familiarity of how a situation can go from casual to angry, only to get stern reminders about the need for empathy. After all, lessons on humanity often have a way of surfacing in the most unexpected of contexts, even if the path is an unsightly detour through bad jokes and regrettable signage.