Trump Cans Copyright Chiefs; Kindle Sales Surge?

Trump Cans Copyright Chiefs; Kindle Sales Surge?

4 minute read
Published: 5/12/2025

In a dramatic move reminiscent of a game of musical chairs, the Trump administration has fired the top copyright official Shira Perlmutter just days after bidding adieu to the Librarian of Congress, Carla Hayden.

Perlmutter's termination, delivered via a White House email, comes on the heels of her report voicing concerns about the use of copyrighted material by AI technology — a topic that seems to have ruffled the feathers of the administration, as Trump is an ardent supporter of artificial intelligence. With the U.S. Copyright Office crucial in protecting creative rights and processing around half a million applications annually, this shake-up raises questions about the direction of copyright policy in a digital world where human creativity seems to be losing the spotlight to machine learning.

Perlmutter’s removal might be seen as quite the punishing blow for the U.S. Copyright Office. Under her competent leadership since her appointment by Hayden in October 2020, the office managed to process an impressive half a million copyright applications per year. Given that the office's primary tasks include registering copyright claims, recording ownership, and administering copyright law, it appears the administration is making some bold choices for an organization critical to protecting the works of human creativity. Perhaps next, they will auction off the role for a reality TV series starring former copyright attorney turned influencer.

While President Trump has consistently acknowledged the bright future of AI technology, the disconnect comes from the Copyright Office's official stance that emphasizes the importance of human creativity in copyright protections. This delicate dance of progress and incumbency begs the question: will AI someday find itself swamped in lawsuits filed by copyright holders in a legal arena reminiscent of a high-stakes chess match? Who would have thought a technology designed to lend efficiency could also lead to a courtroom circus?

In her recently submitted report, Perlmutter articulated concerns over how AI systems utilize copyrighted material, prompting a wave of unease across the intellectual property landscape. After expressing these concerns, Perlmutter was informed of her termination via an email from the White House. A new wattage-inducing twist on the phrase ‘trust but verify’ could soon replace it with ‘automate and annihilate’.

Moreover, Carla Hayden's historical significance as the first woman and first African American to serve as Librarian of Congress adds layers to the unfolding narrative. Was her swift move to appoint Perlmutter a brilliant decision or a gamble that ultimately backfired? One might expect a sense of solidarity in protective roles, but it appears that even in the realm of copyrights, the winds of change can unsettle the most steadfast of ships.

As if that weren't enough, one must ponder the ramifications of these sweeping changes on the burgeoning world of artificial intelligence, which Trump champions with an enthusiasm that far surpasses his affinity for other political causes. If AI and copyright are at odds like oil and water, then it's reasonable to assume we will be seeing some fierce discussions around the café tables in Silicon Valley.

With Perlmutter and Hayden gone, many are left wondering who will take up the mantle of navigating the evolving battleground of copyright issues amid AI’s rise. While the nation holds its breath, we might as well tune into a few more heartfelt tales of creativity in the digital age. After all, human storytelling should not rely solely on algorithms generating plotlines. Let's leave that to machines that have already been auditioning for best supporting actor in their own shows, after all.

So, as the musical chairs continue in Washington, with strange new rules that value AI over artistic integrity, markets worldwide are left holding their breath for the next chapter. Will there be a surge in Kindle sales from authors setting their works to 'open source' in a digital protest? Or will their paperbacks quietly gather dust? One thing is for certain in this ever-evolving narrative: we may need popcorn before we can move from dark satire to non-fiction about how a little creativity was lost along the way.

In any case, the role of copyright in the age of AI should be an ongoing discussion. Because whether you like it or not, our favorite artists are still out there, hoping to catch a break among the electronic symphony of their counterparts. Just remember: the next time your streaming service uses a catchy tune without proper licensing, don’t be surprised if there’s a digital showdown on the horizon that could bring exciting new plot twists to the future of entertainment.