Endurance Swimmer Circles Martha's Vineyard, Avoids Movie Sharks

Endurance Swimmer Circles Martha's Vineyard, Avoids Movie Sharks

4 minute read
Published: 5/26/2025

In a bid to set a swimming world record and change shark stereotypes, Lewis Pugh plunged into 47-degree waters around Martha's Vineyard, armed with a 'Shark Shield' and a passion for conservation.

Lewis Pugh’s unprecedented swim around Martha's Vineyard not only aims for a record but also seeks to rewrite the shark narrative as ‘Jaws’ approaches its 50th anniversary. With nearly 100 million sharks lost annually, Pugh is making a splash for shark conservation, navigating icy waters and combating perceptions that have painted sharks as the nasty villains of the sea—proving that sometimes, it takes an extreme swim to save a finned friend.

Beginning his ambitious swim on May 15, 2025, Pugh is determined to become the first person to circumnavigate the picturesque Martha's Vineyard. And while many might think the challenge is primarily about swimming, he is also up against the chilling waters that hover around a brisk 47 degrees Fahrenheit (8 degrees Celsius). In these temperatures, even the most seasoned swimmer might be tempted to revert to the safety of shore—a place much warmer and filled with snacks.

Pugh’s mission is not just about the swim; he intends to use this journey to highlight the plight of sharks as James Cameron’s cult classic celebrates half a century of instilling dread in ocean-goers. Yes, ‘Jaws’ was set in the idyllic surrounding waters of Edgartown, but its legacy has swayed public opinion by branding sharks as cold-blooded villains, something that Pugh aims to refute—not by reasoning with a great white, but through sheer determination and sheer cold water. 'We need to paint a more accurate picture of these creatures,' Pugh stated. 'They're not out to get us; they're just trying to survive.'

The swimming conditions for Pugh are, to put it mildly, intense. This isn’t his first swim through extreme conditions, having previously braved icy waters near glaciers and even volcanoes. Despite many swimming enthusiasts favoring comfortable, warm waters, Pugh seems unfazed. Who needs a pool when you can battle against Mother Nature while also dodging unpredictable marine wildlife? It appears that challenging ocean swimming is just another day at the office for him.

However, Pugh isn't taking on these frigid waters alone. For this particular adventure, he’s accompanied by a team of safety personnel equipped with a 'Shark Shield' device, a gadget designed to repel sharks during his swim. One can only imagine the conversation at the planning table when discussing what devices might help a swimmer: 'Should we invest in a powerful harpoon or this nifty little gizmo?'. Pugh presumably opted against the harpoon; after all, it might not pair well with his conservation message.

Bringing a bit of statistical shock along for the swim, Pugh is vocal about the staggering numbers that haunt sharks. An eye-opening approximately 274,000 of these creatures are killed globally each day—a figure that spirals to nearly 100 million annually. While being chased by a shark sounds scary, the real terror rests in the numbers that seldom make headlines: the silent genocide within the oceans. While most of us are busy uncovering if summer's flip-flop season can also mean shark sighting season, Pugh is out there wrestling with the waves to bring a much-needed dialogue to the surface.

Moreover, there’s a twist in the plot for those who continue to be gripped in the jaws of fear: both Steven Spielberg, the film's director, and Peter Benchley, the writer of the original novel, have expressed their regrets regarding the terrifying depiction of sharks. In fact, they have shown support for shark conservation efforts, reflecting on how their work shaped ocean perceptions in ways they hadn’t intended. Perhaps it’s time that Hollywood pivots from villainous sharks to a more nuanced view—one that includes a gentle shark with a day job (perhaps as a block party organizer) and a penchant for ballet.

But as the winds whipped through the waters surrounding Martha's Vineyard, Pugh wasn’t just battling the icy grip of the ocean. A nor'easter decided to make an appearance, bringing along an uninvited 7 inches of rain and a healthy helping of flooding to the island. You know you’ve embarked on an epic journey when the weather becomes an additional character in your story—one that absolutely refuses to cooperate.

So, while Pugh continues his swim, he does so not only to conquer a record but to also elevate a broader narrative—one that champions the misunderstood shark rather than vilifying it. His swim around Martha’s Vineyard could prove to be the start of a refreshing dialogue about these essential marine creatures. After all, if one man can swim in freezing waters, face down storms, and stand up for sharks, the least we can do is reconsider our fear while enjoying a beach bonfire. Here’s hoping Pugh’s plunge around the Vineyard will help us all swim a little closer to understanding.