The U.S. government is suing Adobe over its subscription practices, alleging deceptive behavior regarding subscription plans and cancellation fees. Adobe, known for turning even the most mundane tasks into a software odyssey, seems to have outdone itself by converting the act of canceling a subscription into a journey worthy of Odysseus.

A Riddle Wrapped in a Mystery Inside an Enigma

According to the U.S. government, Adobe has been taking cues from ancient producers of infomercials—“But wait, there’s more!” Hidden within the ‘annual, paid monthly’ subscription plans lie hefty early termination fees. Customers, lured in with promises of manageable monthly payments, soon find themselves facing fees that rise faster than a startup's IPO (NY Post, 2024, June 17; CBS News, 2024, June 17).

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) alleges that Adobe concealed key terms of these cancellation fees, which can climb into the hundreds of dollars. That's a sum so staggering it could make you rethink your vow to become the next Picasso of the digital age (NY Post, 2024, June 17; CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Complicated? Understatement of the Year!

Adobe has also been accused of turning the simple act of canceling a subscription into a modern epic. With cancellation as elusive as a Yeti sighting, users often find that the “Cancel Subscription” button is more like an optical illusion, a mirage in a desert of user agreements (NY Post, 2024, June 17; CBS News, 2024, June 17).

The lawsuit, filed in federal court in San Jose, California, seeks civil fines, an injunction, and other remedies. It names Adobe vice president Maninder Sawhney and the president of Adobe’s digital media business, David Wadhwani, as defendants. These executives must now answer for their roles in what can only be dubbed as “Subscription-gate” (NY Post, 2024, June 17; CBS News, 2024, June 17).

That Pesky Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act

The FTC alleges that Adobe’s practices violate the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, an act that we suspect Adobe's legal team might have accidentally filed under “Things We Absolutely Do Not Need To Worry About” (CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Samuel Levine, director of the FTC’s consumer protection bureau, criticized Adobe for “trapping customers with hidden fees and cancellation hurdles.” Much like the mythical minotaur guarding its labyrinth, Adobe’s customer service seems dedicated to keeping users from finding the exit (CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Click to Cancel: A Radical Idea

Lest we think bureaucrats have no imagination, the FTC proposed a ‘click to cancel’ rule in 2023. This law intends to ensure that canceling subscriptions is as easy as enrolling. Meanwhile, over at Adobe HQ, you can almost hear the collective gasp of dismay from the accountant’s office (CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Ironically, Adobe allegedly steered consumers toward its priciest plans without clearly disclosing the associated cancellation costs. How nice of them to provide such personalized financial planning services—with the caveat that all plans lead inexorably to Adobe’s treasure vault (CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Shrouded in Silence

In case you were wondering, Adobe did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Perhaps their spokesperson is lost somewhere in an “InDesign” document or is meticulously editing a Photoshop layer. Whatever the reason, the silence is deafening (NY Post, 2024, June 17; CBS News, 2024, June 17).

Conclusion: A Call for Transparency

For a company celebrated for pushing artistic boundaries, Adobe now finds itself needing to brush up on its ethical transparency skills. Until then, users continue to navigate Adobe’s treacherous subscription waters, hoping to cancel without needing a third mortgage. This litigation shines a spotlight on Adobe's subscription practices and may, just possibly, inject a breath of fresh air into their opaque policies. Until that day, dear users, keep your wits about you—and say a little prayer every time you hit “unsubscribe.”

References