Donovan Mitchell Signs $150M Deal, Cavaliers Bankrupt?

Donovan Mitchell Signs $150M Deal, Cavaliers Bankrupt?

4 minute read
Published: 7/3/2024

Donovan Mitchell, channeling his inner DiCaprio, declared 'I’m not leaving' as he inked a three-year, $150.3 million extension with the Cavaliers, complete with a $54 million player option for 2027-28.

With this lucrative extension, Mitchell cements his short-term future with the Cavaliers, despite nagging injuries and playoff setbacks. Cavalier fans can rejoice—at least until 2027—knowing their star guard isn't planning a dramatic exit just yet. Meanwhile, the coaching staff welcomes Kenny Atkinson, hoping together they can script a more triumphant ending than last season’s semi-final bow-out.

Mitchell's decision to stay came as a surprise to some, especially considering his injury struggles last season. Despite averaging an impressive 26.6 points, 6.1 assists, and 5.1 rebounds per game, the guard was limited to just 55 games due to various ailments. His postseason was equally fraught, as he pushed through a left knee injury before a calf issue sidelined him for the final two games of the Eastern Conference semifinals. Perhaps the Cavaliers should add a bubble wrap supplier to their medical staff for next season!

The observer might wonder if Mitchell's challenge-ridden season influenced the Cavaliers' decision to secure his services long-term. Cavs' president Koby Altman and his staff clearly believe that a healthy Mitchell will be worth every penny of the $150.3 million agreement. 'Donovan is a unique talent,' Altman acknowledged, though not without a chuckle at the contract’s astronomical value. 'His perseverance through injury speaks volumes about his dedication.'

Altman's confidence in Mitchell's value seems well-founded if the star guard can remain healthy. There's no doubt he's a game-changer when fit, as evidenced by the Cavaliers' regular-season performance. However, the dark cloud of last season's playoff elimination by the Celtics still lingers over Cleveland, something new coach Kenny Atkinson will surely want to address in his inaugural season with the team. Hopefully, Atkinson's game plan includes more than just lucky charms against the Celtics.

Atkinson, tasked with leading the Cavaliers post-Bickerstaff era, seems optimistic. 'We've got a solid foundation with Donovan, and we're looking to build on that,' Atkinson remarked, winking as if acknowledging just how 'solid' that financial foundation also happens to be.

Of course, Mitchell's monster deal has not gone unnoticed across the league. The Knicks and the Brooklyn Nets expressed significant interest in trading for him before the Cavs locked him down. Though their interest might have complicated negotiations and put pressure on the Cavaliers, Mitchell’s charismatic 'I’m not leaving' video suggests he’s more than content in Cleveland—or at least with the considerable resources they’ve thrown his way.

Interestingly, Mitchell's contract includes a $54 million player option for the 2027-28 season, which overall makes a ripple in the league's financial landscape. This gives Mitchell flexibility and significant leverage down the line, especially as he's expected to chase an even more lucrative five-year, $380 million deal in 2027. Cavaliers' fans can only hope that such financial posturing doesn't precede an exit later, making this extension a brief, albeit prosperous, pit stop.

The financial gymnastics didn’t stop with Mitchell's deal. Darius Garland's agent reportedly broached the subject of a trade with Koby Altman if the Cavaliers re-signed Mitchell. Their conversations remain behind closed doors for now, but Garland's future could influence the team’s dynamics and chemistry moving forward. After all, managing two star-level contracts is no small feat, even for a team with the Cavaliers' aspirations.

Adding a sprinkle of intrigue to the mix, the Cavaliers won’t be able to trade Mitchell until January 2025, essentially locking both the franchise and player into a somewhat fixed yet luxurious trajectory. This means that, for better or for worse, Mitchell is the Cavaliers' main man for at least the next few seasons. There will be no hiding behind injury reports or playoff misfortunes; it's all in for Cleveland.

Despite the big dollars and bigger expectations, one could argue that such high-stakes contracts mirror the ferry of risks both for the Cavaliers and Mitchell himself—health permitting, naturally. If he stays healthy and guides the Cavaliers to deeper playoff runs, the investment will seem prescient. Conversely, should injuries persist, the team might find themselves in a rather expensive quagmire.

It's evident that the upcoming season promises narrative aplenty—not just with Mitchell's sizeable paycheck but with Kenny Atkinson's new coaching undertakings and potential off-court dramas involving other key players. Whether this hefty outlay will equate to success on the court remains to be seen, but one thing is for certain: Donovan Mitchell is not leaving, for now at least.