Inmate Sentenced to Over Four Years for Killing Gangster Whitey Bulger

Inmate Sentenced to Over Four Years for Killing Gangster Whitey Bulger

3 minute read
Published: 8/3/2024

Paul J. DeCologero was sentenced to over four years in prison for serving as a lookout during the fatal attack on notorious gangster James 'Whitey' Bulger at a West Virginia prison.

DeCologero's sentencing marks a significant development in the aftermath of Bulger's murder, which exposed severe lapses within the federal prison system. The Justice Department's investigation revealed widespread management failures at the Bureau of Prisons, prompting legislative action to enhance oversight. DeCologero, who accepted a plea deal, was one of three inmates involved in the attack that highlighted the dangers posed by internal violence and security shortcomings.

DeCologero was initially charged with murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. However, his role was later clarified, with prosecutors stating that he served as a lookout during the attack on Bulger, rather than participating directly in the physical assault.

The primary assailant in the murder was identified as Fotios 'Freddy' Geas, who struck Bulger with a lock attached to a belt. Another inmate, Sean McKinnon, was also involved as a lookout and was sentenced to time served after admitting to lying to federal agents about his role in the incident.

Prosecutors initially accused both DeCologero and Geas of using the lock to assault Bulger but later confirmed that DeCologero's participation was limited to the role of lookout. This clarification came as part of a plea agreement in which DeCologero changed his plea from not guilty.

During his sentencing hearing, DeCologero declined to speak. However, his attorney conveyed his apology to both Bulger's family and his own, reflecting the complex emotions and ramifications surrounding the case.

The Justice Department opted not to seek the death penalty for DeCologero and Geas. This decision followed an extensive investigation into the systemic flaws within the federal Bureau of Prisons that contributed to Bulger's death. The inspector general's report highlighted significant management failures, incompetence, and flawed policies that created the conditions for the murder to occur.

Following the revelations from the Justice Department's investigation, the U.S. Senate passed legislation aimed at improving transparency and oversight of the Bureau of Prisons. This legislative response underscores the broader implications of Bulger's murder, extending beyond individual culpability to institutional accountability.

James 'Whitey' Bulger was an infamous Boston gangster who evaded capture for years, becoming one of America's most wanted fugitives after fleeing Boston in 1994. He was finally captured in 2011 and subsequently convicted in 2013 of 11 killings and numerous other gangland crimes. Bulger's criminal history and notoriety made his murder a high-profile case, attracting significant public and media attention.

Prior to Bulger's arrival at USP Hazelton, the prison was already under scrutiny for violence and understaffing. Employees had voiced concerns about the volatile environment, which turned out to be tragically prescient given the circumstances surrounding Bulger's death. Court records indicate that inmates had advance knowledge of Bulger's transfer to Hazelton, further complicating the narrative of his murder and highlighting serious security lapses.

The killing took place less than 24 hours after Bulger's transfer to the high-security facility. This swift act of violence raised questions about the adequacy of protective measures for high-profile inmates and the overall security protocols at federal prisons. The case of Whitey Bulger's murder thus serves as a grim illustration of the fatal consequences that can arise from systemic failures in prison management.

In conclusion, the sentencing of Paul J. DeCologero to over four years in prison is a notable development in the aftermath of James 'Whitey' Bulger's murder. While the involvement of DeCologero was less direct compared to the primary assailant, his role as a lookout underscores the complex network of actions and decisions that led to the notorious gangster's death. The case continues to reverberate, driving legislative changes and highlighting the need for significant reforms within the federal prison system.