Director's $11M Netflix Heist: The Movie That Never Screened

Director's $11M Netflix Heist: The Movie That Never Screened

4 minute read
Published: 3/21/2025

In a plot twist worthy of any sci-fi script, filmmaker Carl Erik Rinsch has been charged with wire fraud after allegedly swindling $11 million from Netflix for a show that never aired—'White Horse,' indeed.

Rinsch's alleged antics include requesting an additional $11 million from Netflix for a show that remained a figment of his imagination while he turned the funds into a personal playground, blowing millions on luxury items, vehicles, and even legal fees. As prosecutors prepare their case, the courtroom is set to become the most riveting backdrop since the last Netflix drama—only this time, the plot involves real-life fraud rather than fictional heroes.

The initial investment from Netflix was a staggering $44 million for 'White Horse,' a concept that never leaped from script to screen. After securing the first chunk of change, Rinsch must have felt like a kid in a candy store, or more accurately, like an adult in a luxury car dealership.

When the funds ran low, instead of rushing to the editing suite to wrap up production, Rinsch allegedly decided to dip further into Netflix's deep pockets. He requested that additional $11 million, a request that should have prompted a serious reconsideration of his executive producer badge. It's hard to imagine a more extravagant way to propose a sequel than asking for money to finish what wasn't even started.

However, just when things seemed to be on a stable financial footing, Rinsch’s financial management skills took a nosedive. Within two months, about half of the new $11 million was lost to failed investments. If you were wondering what constitutes a failed investment, think of the classic tale of throwing cash into a bottomless pit, except in this case, the pit had a Netflix subscription but no new releases.

The remnant funds that Rinsch did manage to keep were not returned to Netflix, but rather speculated on cryptocurrency. Miraculously, this gamble paid off, which might explain why he thought trickery could serve him just as well as actually delivering a completed show. Although he didn’t win the lottery, it appears that a few lucky bets on digital currency gave him enough to continue his spending spree for a while longer.

As for what he did with that newfound wealth, the lifestyle Rinsch led wouldn’t have looked out of place in a music video about excess. Approximately $10 million went toward personal expenses, including an eye-watering $2.4 million on Rolls-Royces and Ferraris. Meanwhile, a solid $3.7 million reportedly went toward furniture—presumably, he needed something comfy to sit on while contemplating life choices among all those high-end wheels.

Rinsch’s credit card bill climbed to around $1.8 million. At this point, his plastic was taking on a life of its own—perhaps it was enrolled in its own finance seminar on how to overspend. And let's not forget the $1 million he shelled out on legal fees, which now seems fitting considering the circumstances. There's likely a great discussion over whether it was the lawyers or the furniture that brought him more comfort after the fact.

In a twist that almost mirrors his creative ventures, Rinsch was arrested in the sunlit paradise of West Hollywood and later made an appearance in federal court. The courtroom surely braced itself for the kind of spectacle one wouldn’t expect to see outside of prime-time television—no doubt both the judge and jury were equally left wondering how all these extravagant expenses could be justified by any creative project.

Following his court appearance, Rinsch was released on a $100,000 bond, perhaps paving the way for a chic lifestyle replete with subtle embarrassment upon returning home. Reports indicate that the case against him was filed in New York, though as the saying goes, a charge may travel far but the consequences certainly come closer to home.

Presiding over the courtroom drama was US Magistrate Judge Pedro V. Castillo, who surely hoped for a more traditional narrative. Unfortunately for Netflix and its audience yet eagerly awaiting 'White Horse,' the only drama unfolding was the one in a federal court where prosecutors firmly stated that Rinsch never delivered a completed project nor returned any of the funds borrowed from the streaming giant, leaving viewers wondering just what twist the tale might take next.

As this bizarre chapter of cinematic mayhem continues, one wonders if Rinsch’s next act will involve a grand reveal of 'White Horse' after all—or perhaps just an encore of his financial escapades. Either way, it's clear that for Netflix, nothing leaves quite as sour a taste as a finished script turned into a financial fiasco.